The Stages of the Knife Person Life Cycle
by Phil Elmore
I’ve always believed, on some level, that you are either born with the “knife person” gene or you are not. I can remember, as a young child, wanting a jackknife more than anything. I pestered my parents about it when I was too young, in their eyes, to own such a tool. I remember when my great-grandmother passed away, and I was shown a box of her things (which I dimly remember were being disposed of or given away), I homed in on a small folding knife she used to keep in her sewing kit. I was far too young to own a knife at the time, but I had the gene, even then.
My father always carried a Swiss Army Knife. He carried the big Swiss Champ model. I have vivid memories of him using that knife to open packages on Christmas morning, zipping through the tape that held Kenner Star Wars and Hasbro GI Joe toys hostage. He also used the smallest blade and the tweezers to remove splinters from my fingers.
Dad kept a smaller Swiss Army Knife on his dresser. I know, because I “borrowed” that knife one summer day while he was at work, took it to the local park to whittle twigs, and promptly cut myself. I imagine I got punished for that escapade. It was hard to hide the results of my missteps.
At some point in my pre-teens, my father reluctantly capitulated to my demands for a knife of my own. He presented me with a jackknife, a book on whittling, and the terse instructions, “Cut away from yourself.” Many years later, when I was in college, my grandmother would present me with a very special Christmas gift, too: That knife from my great-grandmother’s sewing kit. (I did some research and I believe the little folder dates to the 1940s, which would be appropriate to the timeframe of the story. I still have it.)
Many badly whittled bars of soap and blocks of wood later, I still loved knives. I always owned one. I remember the first time I ever bought a locking folding knife with my own money. I bought it in a hardware store in my home town (and wrote a paper check for it). It was a Camillus rocker-bar locking folder with “Sword Brand” etched on the blade, comparable to a Buck 110. I wish I still had that one. I’ve no idea where it went, down through the decades.
Regardless of where you start, though, every knife person has two paths. Either you regard the knife as a pocket tool for the rest of your life, the way your grandfather and his father did… or you eventually come to see the knife as a weapon. If you choose the latter path, you are now engaged in the Knife Person Life Cycle.
Stage One: Budding Knife Fighter
Because of my interest in martial arts, I gravitated toward “knife fighting” in the early 1990s. In those days, the only way to get information on this subject was through magazines (such as Fighting Knives magazine, which was on newsstands around that time) or by mail order (such as through Paladin Press, Delta Press, and Loompanics). There was also, of course, popular entertainment — and my peers. In college, I encountered multiple people who owned butterfly knives, a type of knife I’d seen on television and which I found irresistible. I purchased my first one, a cheap chrome model, at Blue Danube Gifts in Olean, New York.
Like so many knives from early in my life, I’ve no idea what eventually became of that poor, beat-up balisong. I’m sure it ended up almost completely rattling itself apart by the time I was done with it. That was only the beginning, though. I got my hands on some early catalog ads for Cold Steel tantos and my tanto obsession was born. The knives were so closely associated with Asian martial arts that, for a time, I bought nothing but Americanized tanto blades.
At this stage of the Knife Person Life Cycle, the budding knife fighter seeks out instruction. In my day, in the early 1990s, that meant books, magazines, and VHS tapes. Later, it meant DVDs. In that first stage, especially given the books from the late seventies and eighties that were on the market at that time, you put a great deal of stock in things like grip and stance. You believe, in your heart of hearts, that a reverse grip is either superior or inferior to a forward grip, that one of those grips (you get to guess which) is the mark of a skilled “knife fighter,” and that one or the other of them affords you greater advantage in a street knife duel.
Today, all this lore, and this stage of the Knife Person Life Cycle, is so much more easily acquired. It’s everywhere on social media. It’s inescapable if you go looking. It’s almost too easy and there’s so much that’s absolutely free. It’s hard not to look at the lore through aging eyes and think that people in their 50s had to earn it, whereas younger knife people coming up are practically handed it for free. Today, the teachers and icons of the knife world with whom I grew up are dying off with alarming rapidity. Lore not committed to print or digital media is being lost forever. The Knife Person Life Cycle, however, continues on.
Stage Two: Money Equals Expertise
You can track these trends down through the last four decades in terms of the knife community overall. As websites, then forums, then social media brought awareness of knife culture to the masses (a mission previously only accomplished through gun and knife shows and print periodicals), people became aware of knives as self-defense tools and then manufacturers got hip to marketing. Suddenly a Buck 110 (once popular with everyone from farmers to bikers and the standard by which an everyday carry (EDC) blade was judged) or a Ka-bar or even an M7 bayonet wasn’t enough. Now you needed a more expensive, purpose-built fighting knife, or you weren’t as cool or skilled as the people who did have one.
Then two things happened: one-hand opening, once the purview of aftermarket bolt-on additions, became common as Spyderco popularized the concept with their opening hole. Then the “tactical knife” concept took the market by the throat. It was a great idea whose time had come: What if your daily-carry utility folding knife could also be a self-defense tool?
The market would never be the same. While there was a bustling trade in fixed blade knives then as now, tactical folding knives became the object of desire for knife people across the community. They have remained a standard and a staple. A knife person who has embraced the budding knife fighter stage invariably begins carrying a tactical folding knife. The more expensive the folding knife, the better equipped he believes he is. Each new knife raises the bar of what is acceptable in terms of cost. Eventually the knife person is spending as much money on a folding knife as some people spend on handguns. He begins to accumulate many knives, then dubs himself a “collector.” There is no turning back now.
Stage Three: Fads and Trends
Stage Three is where the knife person becomes gripped by fads and trends. His accumulation of knives reflects this. Now it isn’t enough to spend more on a fancy knife; he must have a specific fancy knife.
I remember attending a knife class a number of years ago in which the instructor pointed out that the blade profile on a very popular, very expensive tactical folding knife (which I think was a couple of hundred dollars even back then) was not optimal for self-defense. He advocated something basic for self-defense carry, like a Spyderco Endura or even a Spyderco Delica (which were, even then, the Glock of EDC tactical folders: boring, basic, functional, and reliable).
One of the students in the class bristled at the criticism of this blade. He was carrying, not one of them, but two of them, one in the right-side pocket and one in the left-side pocket. It was from this instructor, in fact (whom I’m not naming simply because I don’t want to attribute this to the wrong person, if my memory is faulty), that I learned you should not change the clip on your knife if you carry more than one.
The explanation, just as the criticism of the blade profile, was simple and made sense: If you carry a right-hand knife and a left-hand knife, you have to learn four draws. These are strong side left and right in addition to off hand left and right. If, instead, you carry the same knife twice, configured the same way, you need only learn to draw it with your strong side or your off side, regardless of where it is.
Still, fads and trends continue to dominate the knife person in this stage of their development. They are very susceptible to it and to the marketing that delivers a new fad or trend to the audience. I am no exception. I was right there, interested in each new knife of the moment as it rolled out. I wanted so many of them, and bought quite a few. I’ve sold my collection multiple times over, only to accumulate more. Something funny started to happen, though, and that’s how I realized (after the fact) that I was moving out of Stage Three. That was that I started to see beyond the lore of Stage One and tool expense of Stage Two.
Stage Four: Beyond Grip and Stance
When the knife person enters Stage Four, he begins to look at the lore he accumulated as a budding knife fighter and discard it. In part, this is due to achieving, through years of training, competence and his own style of doing things. You learn that a knife grip is less important than having a knife; that the few centimeters’ difference in a forward grip versus a reverse grip is less important than where your hips and shoulders are positioned.
Knife stances that seemed so important to learn, including which ones were superior to which, get lost when you start doing actual force-on-force training. The lobster-clawed adrenaline rush of gross motor reflexes left you in a force-on-force encounter teaches you that you’re not going to do any fancy grip transitions or switches. In a real-life encounter, which the knife person may even have had at this point, you know what it feels like for your balls to crawl back up into your abdomen while you struggle to apply basic movements instilled in you through training. The threat is coming and you’ve got to meet it, but you don’t want to, because you also know that legal trouble will follow.
It’s in Stage Four that the realities of knife combatives really start to take hold. You’re no longer fascinated by the fantasy of “knife fighting,” though you still buy the books and watch the social media videos and enjoy a good movie climax involving knives. By Stage Four, though, you’re now thinking about the aftermath, the courts, the insurance, the consequences.
It’s no longer an action movie or a television show. It’s no longer a fantasy. It’s now a cautionary tale, something to be avoided. You started learning “knife fighting” because it was cool and sexy. You kept learning knife combatives because, like having fire insurance, you might have an emergency one day. You hope it doesn’t happen. You fervently wish that moment never comes. You keep preparing anyway.
Stage Five: Beyond Tools and Brands
By Stage Five, you’ve let go of even the pretense of expensive tools. Now you’re comfortable fighting with a three-dollar utility razor or a rusty screwdriver from your tackle box… and you realize the power both possess when it comes to self-defense. This isn’t about bravado or even the trend and fad of “hobotactical” minimalism; it’s simple physics.
Physics and physiology govern Stage Five, when you’ve made the connections and you’ve had the training. Now you no longer worry about whether you own the most expensive, most trendy knife. You’ve let go of stance and grip as something that really matters. You’re only worried about consistent performance in an adrenalized state… and how to avoid having to perform at all if you can.
The fun thing about being a knife person in Stage Five, though, is that all the stuff that mattered in the previous four stages still interests you. It’s still fun. It’s still part of being in the knife community, of enjoying knives as tools, of realizing that knives are also incredibly useful defensive weapons.
I still buy knives I don’t need and won’t use. I still buy knife fighting books. I still watch knife fighting videos. Hell, I still train in new styles of knife fighting. I’m even an instructor in edged weapons. The stages of the Knife Person Life Cycle came and went, but my knife person gene is always with me. The fact that you’ve progressed through the stages doesn’t mean you’ll eventually leave knives behind. There is, in fact, no escape.
Prognosis: Terminal
No, the prognosis for every knife person is a terminal one. You were born a knife person or acquired the gene early in life. You will die a knife person, hopefully never knowing if that “knife fighting” stuff would have worked when you needed it. You will go to your grave loving knives and, who knows? Maybe you’ll even be buried with one or two. Maybe your friends — as mine have — will reach out to you and ask and honor you: Could you see to the disposition of their collections when they pass? You will accept, and gratefully. There is no greater vote of confidence from a knife person. You may one day ask the same of others. They, too, will be honored.
To live and die as a knife person is to understand the utility and, yes, the allure of one of the most basic of all tools. If the first tools ever picked up by mankind were a rock and a stick, the first tool actually made was a cutting edge. The cutting edge makes all other tools possible. It makes civilization possible. No matter how advanced our species becomes, no matter how advanced our tools become, the basic form factor of the knife will not change. The basic tasks a knife can accomplish, likewise, will always be the same. Materials, edge-holding, cutting power… these may improve. Their fundamental place in our lives will not.
No matter where you find yourself in the Knife Person Life Cycle, you find yourself in good company. The rest of us are right here with you, cheering you along. We are all in this alone together, as the man once said… but I can think of no better community than one whose members recognize the everyday usefulness of a good knife. Whether for utility or self-defense, the knife is essential.
It always will be.